
Part Two: The One-Man Intelligence Operation Against ISIS
Sasha Ingber: Welcome to SpyCast, the official podcast of the International Spy Museum. I'm your host, Sasha Ingber, and each week I take you into the shadows of espionage, intelligence, and covert operations across the globe.
Historian and scholar Omar Mohammed became a spy without a spy service after ISIS took control of his city, Mosul, in 2014. It was art as much as science, mixing truth with lies, blending his real identity and social network with invented jobs as doctors, mechanics, and taxi drivers. Omar gathered unparalleled insight into the terrorist organization's capabilities, its tactics, its vulnerabilities, and he shared that information on social media under the name Mosul Eye, now the title of his memoir. This is the second part of our conversation, which focuses on key sites that he exposed, his closest calls, and a perilous escape literally in the company of a member of ISIS. We left off with Omar talking about a man who was related to the head of the Islamic state intelligence, and now he describes how he gained that man's trust and turning him into an unwitting source through the prospect of love and marriage.
Omar Mohammed: Let's say one of the things, he was not exactly the type of person who would always project that image of, "Oh, he's completely devoted to God," et cetera. He was going to the university, he wanted to get married to a professor from the university, but he was never able to talk to her. He mentioned that woman to me once, and I said, "I know this woman. I know this professor." I mean, it was risky to do what I did. In that sense, I can tell him things even though they never happened. I said, "Oh, I met with this professor and she mentioned you. She said she had seen you because you worked also at the library when they were rewriting the education correctly."
And then he started wanting to see me more. He started wanting to talk to me more because he thought I had access to that professor and it might help him to really eventually propose to her and marry her. So I kept it like that. I kept giving information, but then I was at one point really, I didn't know what to do. What if he speaks to her and she mentions that she never met with me? What if that happens? So once again, I invented the reason for me and her to interact, even just to pass by or just to exist in the same location in one of those moments of that eternal time. So if he meets her, she would say, “Yes, I saw Omar,” and it's kind of like it's my cover. He failed for it. I never asked him questions. I never told him, tell me this, tell me that. He was really singing like a bird. I just set the trap for him. And there are other points where they started giving more information and at one point it started becoming easier and easier.
Then I understood that actually it's not that I had the advantage, is that they really never suspected me. I really spoke when I was there, but I always have this ability of being the passive-aggressive person in the room. I realized eventually in such a situation, the best source was using your personal connections.
Sasha Ingber: So many spies who are underestimated are the most successful in their trade craft. I'm sure it was incredibly difficult to see your friends join ISIS if it was not about survival, if they had really become radicalized to see that happen. And doing this work must have been part of what kept you surviving through the violence of watching that happen.
Omar Mohammed: I mean, you know, Sasha, I feel sad for the people I knew who joined the Islamic state. It was really sad. I mean, that one, the mall, at one point when I thought that he'd exposed me, I was going through this dilemma. I was like, I'm going to get rid of him. I'm going to geo-locate him, make him a target. Should I do it? Should I not? Because if I don't do it, he survives. I don't.
Sasha Ingber: Would you have reported him?
Omar Mohammed: Yeah, I would have. Who is more important? Him or Mosul? He was the enemy. He was no longer my friend. To me, he was not a friend. To me, he was the vessel that I used to cultivate information. Him as a friend ceased to exist the moment he chose. You mentioned those ideologicals. He was also ideological. There were others who were completely 100% ideological. And even those who joined for non-ideological reasons, but one month inside the Islamic state or even one day inside the Islamic state would have been enough for anyone to know you are on the wrong side. You've seen them enslaving women, enslaving children, deporting people, indigenous to the land, to this place, and you see the destruction exclusions publicly in the public squares. Whether people joining them ideologically or non-ideologically, I think there is no excuse. So yes, 100% I would have reported him.
Sasha Ingber: Two of the most significant places that you showed the world were one, a place where ISIS was manufacturing car bombs and then two, a chemical weapons unit. Can you say more on all of that?
Omar Mohammed: So one of the most significant sites back then was in the northwest of the city in the industrial area, and that site was also a former industrial complex that was run by the Iraqi government. Which meant back then is that it has the infrastructure of being reused. It was not a military site back then, but it was a site that had infrastructure to allow for manufacturing. And in that complex was where ISIS was developing its drone program, its car bombs program, but also eventually suicide drones.
Sasha Ingber: Suicide drones?
Omar Mohammed: Yes. It's there when they test because also ISIS had an air defense division and they had an air defense development program. In fact, they even, after the deliberation of Mosul, the Iraqi military captured a site where ISIS was experimenting, creating its own helicopters. Anyway, back to that site, which was giving ISIS really advantage no one had. I just couldn't let it go. I kept going by that site. I had to once again, as I always said before, I had to invent reasons to be there. I had to utilize the connections I have. I had to work in a workshop before in front of that complex for some days.
And of course I used my brother to drive me many times. The thing related to that site is that it was a high value site and I needed to understand what it was to confirm before I reported. I had to work as a car repairman. I had to pretend that I actually work in repairing cars in a workshop with all of that dust, with all of that oil. And this is exactly what I had to do. It was worth it.
Sasha Ingber: Because that site got destroyed?
Omar Mohammed: It's gone, yes. I don't know how, but it's gone.
Sasha Ingber: And what about the chemical weapons unit?
Omar Mohammed: I had heard information that they were doing chemical experiments inside the university, and then I started actually developing my information about which site it might be, et cetera. Once again, the highly likely site was in the complex of the science departments because it also once again had the infrastructure for that. And I collected the information. I kept going inside the university.
Sasha Ingber: As what?
Omar Mohammed: I mean, I am a former professor at the university, so I had that access, but I also used other reasons to go there. Once I had gathered the information, it was a type of information that was once again complete, which also led to the dismantling of that department.
Sasha Ingber: Meaning it was hit with an airstrike?
Omar Mohammed: We later hear that the university was targeted.
Sasha Ingber: Now, when you were receiving information, did you confirm that this was authentic, that you weren't being lured into a trap?
Omar Mohammed: There were many ways. The verification, one, for example, if it's the type of information I would receive myself, but when I had left the city, it was more of a way of verification. For example, during the rescue missions, I had to speak to people directly. I had to use anonymous numbers and call them. I had to ask them questions. I had to verify things, but then also I had to compare it to other sources. The same information, I had to confirm it with no less than four sources. It was always comparing information against multiple sources, and sometimes it ends in verification. Sometimes it never does. It was a challenge.
Even when I was there on the ground, sometimes it becomes difficult because one piece of the information cannot be verified because that person in question no longer exists. It becomes dead information. I have a feeling it is accurate, it is authentic, but if I don't have the evidence that it is authentic, I would never use it. I put it down, I keep it, but I would never use it.
Sasha Ingber: What was the closest call you had while you were doing this in Mosul?
Omar Mohammed: I mean, one of them was when I mentioned the same guy I had used as a mall. He'd mentioned a piece of information because he just asked me how do you verify? It took me a year and one time he just spoke of something and then what he said was actually the missing piece that just verified something for me from a year ago and I was so happy. I went home rushing, I've verified that information. Now I know that those who were killed are not what ISIS said because ISIS back then claimed that this is a civilian site. It was not. It was the first meeting, 17 senior leaders of ISIS were killed in that airstrike, but they never announced that.
Sasha Ingber: Didn't want to admit the defeat?
Omar Mohammed: Yes, exactly. Particularly it's the first days of the occupation of ISIS. And then I realized what I have done, I've fallen in the trap. There is no way if he read that information, there is no way he would not say, "Well, Omar is Mosul Eye." I was so excited. That's why I am always afraid of emotions and feelings, and it's more about discipline.
Sasha Ingber: But he didn't put the two together?
Omar Mohammed: Because I took action immediately and removed it and it never went public. And then the next day I wanted to verify that. I wanted to know, did he expose me? And he did not. There was another moment. At one point it became really almost impossible to get internet connection, but with ISIS, they always had internet connection and I was desperate to transmit that information. How to do it. After all, you cannot also declare Mosul Eye dead because that would mean if you are not reporting, that would mean they will really zoom in on you. And I've always wanted to avoid that. That's why I would report at any cost from any location. One of the times that I really had to, oh my God, the only place that had internet was the house of the head of the intelligence of ISIS. I used Mosul Eye from inside that house.
I used Mosul Eye while in the same room while sitting the head of Intelligence of ISIS. I reported that phone was connected to the internet. And of course, once it's connected, information is gone. That's all I need. I don't need to keep myself surfacing internet browsing. No. All I need is just a signal for the information to go. I mean, you can imagine. I mean, sometimes I thought about that. I think it was reckless. I think I should not have done it, but also was the alternative, you know?
Sasha Ingber: Yeah. I wonder how many times you did that.
Omar Mohammed: Yeah. And I always call it reckless, but I always tell myself, what is the alternative?
Sasha Ingber: I'm sure that intelligence agencies contacted you because they were interested in what you were providing. Was there ever a moment when you felt like maybe it would be nice to have their support?
Omar Mohammed: They would contact, they would reach out. But as I always say, everything I have made public, it was done publicly. I transformed that because part of what I was doing was breaking that circle and that cage that ISIS used to put the city in. ISIS was running on secrets and information. I made them public. That was my game. My game is exposing ISIS the way it is, and this was always my response to whoever contacts me, the intelligence, governments, law enforcement back then. I say, "The information is public. You can take it for free. You don't have to have me working for you. What you need is there, is available, and it helped people. It helped intelligence, it helped journalism, it helped researchers, everyone who needed type of information." Because back then I had no idea who was watching Mosul Eye. I know people who were following Mosul Eye. I know people who are interacting with Mosul Eye. I know it was impacting the people back then. But the last thing I was thinking about is having an affiliation with anyone. I did not want to do any of that. But later on when the battle began, that stance I had was no more because I saw the opportunity. I took it and the opportunity was utilizing the presence of the CENTCOM online to use them to help them rescue people. Over 92 families were rescued through communication with the CENTCOM.
Sasha Ingber: Central command.
Omar Mohammed: The Central Command on Twitter.
Sasha Ingber: When we come back, how Omar was smuggled out of Mosul, sitting next to an ISIS fighter and with hard drives that would have incriminated him.
Now you did flee Iraq.
Omar Mohammed: Yes.
Sasha Ingber: In December of 2015, you escaped to Europe through Turkey. Pick us up from there.
Omar Mohammed: When I decided to flee Mosul, we knew that smugglers would also be complicit with ISIS, otherwise they would not be allowed to move around, but they were also working for themself, so I had to rely on that as well. I needed to escape Mosul. I had to escape Mosul.
Sasha Ingber: What made you need to flee at that moment?
Omar Mohammed: They were closing in. ISIS was closing in. They were losing their headquarters. Everything was being dismantled. Everything was being destroyed. They were coming inside the residential areas. In the house where I lived, next door was the senior ISIS leader. On the street, their land to air defense. Next door was a warehouse where they piled up weapons. There are snipers outside, but also house search randomly every day. They were closing in. There was no chance my family or I would survive. There was no chance. I had to eliminate that condition for my family to survive. That's the only reason I escaped. I found a smuggler. I did not mean to travel. Next day he said, "I'm leaving tomorrow. Would you like to come?" I said, yes. I went back. I immediately packed up everything and everything here I mean is I transformed my entire laptop into hard drives, which is the archives of everything I did against ISIS.
Mosul Eye, it's information, it's documents, it's videos, everything. I thought we were going to just drive directly. That's it. We are in the smuggling mood now. He said, no, we have to go to the garage, the station that ISIS had built before we go directly. And when we arrived there, oh my God, what the hell happened? Someone got into the car with his AK-47. He's a member of the Islamist. I said, "That's the end of it. I'm done." But then he was a passenger. I mean, the stress I had lived during that moment, I tried to distract him in the car. I saw a copy of the Quran. I told him, "Why don't you read Quran? Your voice must be really amazing." He bought that and he started reading, so I kept him distracted. But as horrifying as it may be, it was also my ticket to escape Mosul, that actually when we arrived at the largest checkpoint between Iraq and Syria, when they saw him in the car, they just let us go.
And you can imagine sitting in the car next to me as a member of ISIS. Beneath me is the harder drives and my smartphone with everything in it is screaming Mosul Eye. It was the longest trip of my entire life, but we crossed.
Sasha Ingber: I'm stressed just hearing about it.
Omar Mohammed: We crossed into Syria. He's no longer with us, and the situation in Syria was much different from that of Mosul because everything that started from an area called Shaddadi, it's very close on the borders with Iraq. I would see the people being crucified. I saw a living human being. ISIS had put in a pickup and dogs were eating his feet. I saw that one who was crucified. I still remember his name. It had a sign with the name Suleiman. I don't know if he was dead or not. I can never forget these images in my entire life. He drove me to Raqqa, and near Raqqa, I thought, he said we will stop, eat, and then that's what he told me. But I looked and then he disappeared. He's no longer there. And then I found out that they have agreements with Syrian smugglers who picked me up from there, took us to the safe house that was owned by the smuggler.
There were other people waiting and then took us to the borders with Turkey. He said we will wait the right moment in the middle of the night, in the depth of the night, that unknown fate. There's a trench, you'll have to go down and then climb up. I saw in that trench a large man who found it really difficult to climb on his own, and then it was very easy for me to do it. I said no. I told him, look, I'm going to push you up. I'm going to help you. Do not leave me after I push you up. Don't leave me behind. I'm going to help you. Do not leave me behind. Sasha, I pushed him up. He gave me his hand. I don't know what happened. He left me. He just left me. He left me behind and he started running. I fell.
And the moment I fell, the border police started shooting, and then I am 30 minutes in that trench. I though it was my grave. I think at one point it was my grave. I mean, I don't believe in this superstitious things, but I think I died during that moment because I was free from every fear I had in my life. 30 minutes waiting in that trench, not knowing what's going to happen. Border police is shooting at you from the outside. If you go back, it's ISIS and the dark is covering everything. Actually, my safe space was my heaven, actually it was, all the music.
Sasha Ingber: Which you couldn't play in ISIS controlled Mosul.
Omar Mohammed: Yeah, exactly. I was hearing it again in my mind, that piece of music of Itzhak Perlman. I mean, he's my favorite musician. And the images that were coming to me is so funny is that I did not imagine something from yesterday or from last year or from... What was coming to my mind is that character of the pianist in the film called the pianist when he just survived and he was so hungry, he was trying to open a can of cucumber in the middle of nowhere in Poland during the Second World War, and he was a pianist. His hands could not... I mean, he could play music, but he doesn't know how to open a canned cucumber.
And I was imagining that, but I was also imagining my life what it was. And looking at this, it was the end. And then a voice would come speaking in a Eastern Syria dialect telling me, "I am here. Don't worry. I will not leave you. I promise you I will save you." I said, "This must have been God telling me you are not dead." He showed up. His name was Steph. It's a short version of saying Mustafa. That was the name of the smuggler, the Syrian one. I saw him again. He said, "Don't worry. We found a lower part of the trench. Follow me." I followed him with the bag still on me. He said, "When you cross, keep running. Do not stop. Do not look behind. Do not take a breath. Don't stop. Just keep running." I kept running. I did not know I was actually running on rocks. I was actually running very fast, but I did not know I was running on rocks.
On the other side, after probably 10 minutes of running, I started hearing the voice, someone telling me, "You don't have to run anymore. You are safe. Calm down." This was the smugglers' collaborator from the other side of the border. And then we drove to Urfa, where I started from there to many other cities. I had to stay in hiding in Turkey as well. I had to keep running from a city into another. In the beginning, I spent most of my time on buses because buses would drive for 14 or 16 hours across cities because the plans I had prepared, they proven to be really not working. The person who had promised me a place there disappeared, no longer responds to me. I was left alone.
Sasha Ingber: Omar, your journey was utterly harrowing and you went through so much before the escape even began. When you think about the psychological toll, I mean, Pope Francis wrote the foreword to your book writing, "I pray to God that Omar may feel relief in his heart wounded by suffering."
Omar Mohammed: Yes. My heart is suffering, I know. I don't even know if I have a heart anymore, but I do know it is a wounded heart. My soul is wounded. I mean, part of me disappeared. For example, what people know as a normal life, I don't know. Even if I want to be a normal person again, I don't know any more what being normal means. Am I complaining? Absolutely not.
As I mentioned earlier, and I will say it, would it happen again? I would do it again. I would stand the rest of my life against any terrorism that tries to take life from this life, from our normal ordinary life. We don't need terrorists to tell us how to speak to God, how to pray to God. We don't need terrorists to tell us how to read history, how to live life. We have a system. We have democracy. We make mistakes. We correct them tomorrow. We don't need terrorists to tell us what is right, what is wrong. That's why I will definitely always continuously side against them.
Sasha Ingber: So it was worth the sacrifices that you made and the atrocities that you bore witness to?
Omar Mohammed: 100% worth it.
Sasha Ingber: And in 2017, you decided to reveal your identity to the Associated Press who published an article. I'm interested in knowing why you chose that moment and then how your family responded.
Omar Mohammed: It's a lonely job. You are surrounded by people no matter how many, but you are alone. I was all alone. In Paris, I was alone, even though I was surrounded by people, wonderful people among my family, a wonderful family, but I was alone. I could not tell anyone what I fear. I had to continuously pretend and manufacture feelings, and then it really was crushing. And I came to the moment that I said it's done. I have to reveal my identity now. I can no longer remain anonymous. I have to reclaim life again. The funny part of the AP is that AP was speaking to me while I was anonymous, and they were verifying information, asking me to verify it for them. And then I told the journalist, "Would you like to tell the story?" And that journalist responded when she was coming to the location, she did not know I was on site because I was monitoring her movement, understanding if she's bringing someone with her, if she's the right person. How do I know?
Sasha Ingber: Did you do that today?
Omar Mohammed: I definitely did.
Sasha Ingber: I get it now. I get it. So you chose that moment. What did your mother think? You have your brother as an unwitting participant.
Omar Mohammed: The thing that my family, particularly my mother told me, she says she's proud, but she also told me as any mother would do, "I've always suspected you have been hiding something." But also my brother told me he would have been disappointed if I have never done what I did. I mean, this was the moral support that I needed, that my family told me, "We are happy that you did what you did," even though it was painful to them. But I'm glad. I mean, you also call it suffering, probably. I mean, I had many funny moments during that time. I can stick to those funny moments and I forget about everything else.
I fell in love during that period, and then I lost love again. I know that I taught people how to avoid getting killed by ISIS, and they were effective in reporting against ISIS. One of them was a wonderful young woman who really became the female voice of Mosul, and I mentioned her in my book as well. I'm happy that people are back to their life now. Very hard it is, of course indeed. But look where we are now. It's over 12 years from 2014, and we are in Washington talking about that period, but not about dead Omar. Omar is still alive. That's what matters. Where is ISIS? ISIS is gone.
Sasha Ingber: On that note, the structure of ISIS has changed. It's decentralized, but they still exist in parts of Africa. We still see them in Afghanistan, in Pakistan.
Omar Mohammed: In Iraq, Sasha, two days before the US withdrawal from Iraq, there were clashes in Kirkuk between suicide bombers. Three of them were killed and the driver was wounded and taken. They're around.
Sasha Ingber: Right. They're around. And when you think about what you endured and what the Moslawis endured, what would you suggest in terms of dismantling them because they can't be fully destroyed?
Omar Mohammed: Yes. There are two key elements in any fight against terrorism. One, the superiority of information. We must have superiority of information, and that can only be done when you understand the context and the nature of the land where the Islamic state lives, and that ideological background, that ideological setting, et cetera. So information, information, information is always very important. And the second thing is people. We have to continuously educate people about what terrorism is. People might say, for example, Muslim Brotherhood is not violent, but come on. Al-Qaeda was built on an idea from the Muslim Brotherhood. Hamas was built on the structure of the Muslim brotherhood, and the Muslim Brotherhood is non-violent. It takes an ideology to establish a violent organization, so we should never ignore these facts. No matter how small they are, we should always understand that it starts in that non-violent level, but will eventually go violent.
I think there is something really concerning about how that discourse of terrorism is changing. Don't forget that sometimes one brand of terrorism goes down, there is another one emerges. So terrorism never ends, that's true. But that doesn't mean we can also stop monitoring them, observing them.
Sasha Ingber: Have all of the personas of Mosul Eye ended or is there still some work?
Omar Mohammed: Well, there are still some, yes. I mean, I have to. It's Iraq, it's a complicated country.
Sasha Ingber: Wow.
Omar Mohammed: Yeah.
Sasha Ingber: I wanted to end by remembering a presentation that you gave a few years ago because I also spied on you digitally. You started it off by saying, "I can't believe I'm still alive standing here." Now I wanted to ask-
Omar Mohammed: I can't believe I am alive now.
Sasha Ingber: You're alive. You're wearing multicolored socks.
Omar Mohammed: I like them.
Sasha Ingber: I wanted to leave by asking you what you want your life to look like now.
Omar Mohammed: I really want a boring life. I want a boring life. I want to be with my cat. But I mean, seriously, I'm hopeful to see that transition in the areas that were damaged by terrorism, that they are no longer sources of terrorism, but rather sources of hope, sources of development, sources of culture, sources of art, cities like Mosul, Aleppo, Damascus, but also Kabul. Unfortunately, Kabul is living under that terrorism again by Taliban. But there are other areas that are suffering from that ideological mindset.
Sasha Ingber: Okay. But remember I asked about your life.
Omar Mohammed: I don't know. I mean, I don't know. I don't know if I will ever have a normal life. I don't know if I will ever have the moment to think about my life. I never did. I mean, I'm alive. I can eat. I can drink. Water, of course. I can walk, I can move, I can travel. I'm in the United States. I travel back and forth between United States and Europe. I teach. I'm doing many things. That's enough for me. But these dreams I had, those feelings I once enjoyed, they're all gone. I don't know how to get them back, but they're all gone. I'm sorry, I don't have an answer. I don't know what to think. I don't know what to think about myself. I mean, I dedicated myself to this cause.
Sasha Ingber: The important work you did, it came at a cost, and being honest about that is okay.
Omar Mohammed: Yes. It's a very difficult question. It would've been easier for me to tell me how did you take down an entire intelligence terrorism. I would've done it easier than thinking about what do I want to do in my life because I don't know. I just wish one day to really find time to sit with myself, one time, one day. I want to see a word free from terrorism, a word free from that concern of terrorism. That would be my reward. Yeah, that would be my reward.
Sasha Ingber: Omar, thank you so much for coming in to share your story and this book, Mosul Eye, with us.
Omar Mohammed: Sasha, thank you for having me to tell my boring story.
Sasha Ingber: You certainly have a sense of humor on you, we'll give you that. As if you didn't do important things.
Omar Mohammed: Thank you, Sasha.
Sasha Ingber: Thanks for listening to this episode of SpyCast. If you liked the episode, give us a follow on Apple, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts. And leave us a rating or a review, it really helps. If you have any feedback or you want to hear about a particular topic, you can reach us by email at SpyCast@spymuseum.org. I'm your host, Sasha Ingber, and this show is brought to you by N2K Networks, Podville Media, and the International Spy Museum in Washington, DC.


